CHANGE MY POLICY Change My Policy We make it as easy as possible to change your policy by listing the companies we insure with. ASI - American Strategic Insurance Phone Number: 1-866-274-5677 Website Auto-Owners Insurance Phone Number: 1-800-288-8740 Website Foremost Insurance Group Website Progressive Insurance Phone Number: 1-855-347-3939 Website Travelers Insurance Phone Number: 800-842-5075 Website Wright Flood Insurance Website